How Consumers are Taking The Wheel of Brand Narratives

By
Fraser Hay
-
How Consumers are Taking The Wheel of Brand Narratives

There is a shift towards consumer-driven brands and user-generated content. Businesses need to either adapt or risk being left behind

In 2024, the relationship between businesses and consumers underwent a profound transformation. Social media, with its expansive reach and participatory nature, has reshaped how brands communicate and connect with audiences. The traditional approach—where businesses controlled the narrative and dictated the brand message—has been replaced by consumer-driven storytelling. Today, individuals actively shape and redefine brands, forcing businesses in 2025 to relinquish some control. This era demands a collaborative and transparent approach, one that values user-generated content (UGC) as the driving force behind this shift.

The Rise of Consumer Influence

Social media platforms like Instagram, TikTok, and Twitter have empowered consumers like never before. Armed with the ability to voice opinions, share experiences, and influence perceptions, individuals have become co-creators of brand narratives. This evolution has fundamentally altered the balance of power between brands and their audiences.

Research from Sprout Social reveals that 47% of consumers have used social media to express dissatisfaction with a brand’s customer service. Of those, 80% expect a response within 24 hours. This immediacy and accessibility mean businesses can no longer control their narratives unilaterally. Instead, they must engage in real-time, two-way conversations to maintain credibility and trust.

READ MORE: Brand Priorities for 2025

My daughter Lauren, a young mother with two small children, regularly creates short video posts on TikTok and Instagram for FTSE100 and Fortune 100 brands while working from home. She receives a brief, agrees on the payment and usage rights, and then creates video content sharing her personal experiences with various products and services on camera. Agencies review several versions of her submissions, select the best one, and publish it. Once her content goes live, she gets paid.

UGC as a Game-Changer in Brand Power Dynamics

User-generated content is at the heart of this power shift. By sharing authentic customer experiences, UGC hands the reins of branding to consumers, transforming them into brand advocates—or critics. This relinquishment of control is not a liability but a competitive advantage when leveraged effectively.

Example: Crocs’ Remarkable Comeback

Once dismissed as unfashionable, Crocs has become a cultural phenomenon by embracing consumer-driven trends. Through partnerships with designers and celebrities and encouraging UGC on platforms like TikTok and Instagram, Crocs tapped into the “ugly” fashion trend. The hashtag #CrocsOnTheRise, widely used in 2024, generated over 2 million posts and boosted the brand’s sales by 20% year-over-year (The Atlantic, 2024). By aligning with consumer preferences, Crocs turned its perceived weaknesses into strengths.

Example: Starbucks’ #RedCupContest

Starbucks’ annual #RedCupContest is another illustration of UGC’s impact. Every holiday season, the brand invites customers to share creative photos of their iconic red cups, generating tens of thousands of posts. In 2023, the campaign reached 35 million impressions and increased in-store sales by 12% during the holiday period. By celebrating consumer creativity, Starbucks transforms its customers into co-creators of their brand narrative.

Challenges of Losing Control—and Mitigating Risks

While UGC offers undeniable benefits, businesses must navigate challenges, including:

  1. Viral criticism: A single viral complaint can tarnish a brand’s reputation. For instance, negative reviews or misinterpreted campaigns can quickly gain traction, causing a reputational crisis.
    Mitigation strategy: Active social listening and rapid, transparent responses can help businesses address concerns before they escalate.
  2. Platform dependency: Over-reliance on specific platforms can leave businesses vulnerable to algorithm changes or bans, as seen with TikTok’s uncertain future in the US.
    Mitigation strategy: Diversify your social media presence across multiple platforms to reduce risks and maintain engagement.
  3. Content authenticity: The rise of AI-generated content makes it harder to discern genuine customer experiences from fabricated ones.
    Mitigation strategy: Invest in tools to verify content authenticity and maintain trust with your audience.

Making UGC Strategies Scalable for Small Businesses

UGC may seem resource-intensive, but small businesses can adopt scalable approaches:

  1. Encourage organic sharing: Create unique hashtags and invite customers to share their stories or reviews. A local coffee shop, for example, could encourage patrons to tag their latte art with a hashtag for a chance to be featured on the shop’s Instagram page.
  2. Collaborate with micro-influencers: Partnering with influencers who have smaller but highly engaged audiences can yield high ROI without the hefty price tag of celebrity endorsements.
  3. Leverage free tools: Use platforms like Canva to repurpose customer photos and reviews into engaging posts. Affordable analytics tools can also help track campaign performance.

Embracing the Shift: Strategies for Success

To thrive in this evolving environment, businesses must adopt UGC-driven strategies that prioritise collaboration, authenticity, and adaptability:

  1. Engage in active listening: Monitor consumer sentiment and respond promptly using social listening tools.
  2. Foster authentic relationships: Build trust by highlighting real stories and addressing concerns transparently.
  3. Encourage co-creation: Involve customers in product development or branding campaigns to deepen loyalty.
  4. Diversify platforms: Expand your social media presence to minimise platform dependency risks.
  5. Reward engagement: Offer incentives, such as discounts or recognition, to encourage UGC contributions.

The Outlook for 2025

The shift toward consumer-driven branding signals more than a trend; it represents a fundamental change in how businesses and consumers interact. UGC is the cornerstone of this transformation, redefining the relationship between brands and their audiences. By embracing UGC, businesses relinquish some control but gain the opportunity to build deeper connections and foster a sense of community.

As examples like Starbucks and Crocs demonstrate, the most successful brands are those that share the stage with their consumers, co-creating stories that resonate and inspire. For small and large businesses alike, the key to thriving in 2025 lies in valuing consumer voices, maintaining authenticity, and adapting quickly to the ever-changing digital landscape.

In this collaborative future, businesses that integrate UGC into their strategies will not only strengthen their brand but also inspire lasting loyalty—turning their customers into their greatest ambassadors.

ALSO READ: The Fusion of Meta Skills and AI Will Fuel CX Growth